A New Standard of Indulgence.
Featuring Organic A2A2 Dairy.
Incredible Mouthwatering Flavors.
And Only The Purest Ingredients.

First time ordering with us?

Claim your free pint Shop

Welcome! We’re
so glad you are

At Goodness Dairy, we have crafted a new standard of indulgence that harmonizes wholesome goodness with irresistible mouthwatering flavor. Our ice cream is built around New York’s finest organic 100% grass-fed A2A2 dairy from small regenerative family farms. And we use only honey and organic maple syrup from New York and Vermont to sweeten. Our mission is to offer a delicious range of flavors that delight the senses and nourish the body. No refined sugar, no syrups, no seed or vegetable oils, no gums, fillers or stabilizers, and no GMOs or artificial anything. Join us in our quest to create a healthier, happier world, one spoon of our meticulously crafted, mouthwatering ice cream at a time.

Shop Online! Currently Shipping to The
Entire East Coast, Ohio & Tennessee.

Golden Milk From
Green Pastures

Our ice cream is proudly made with the finest
quality 100% grass-fed A2A2 milk from Family
Farmstead Dairy
, which represents a handful of
small family farms in upstate New York who are
all certified organic and certified regenerative. With
each delectable spoon of our ice cream, you are
supporting New York's finest dairy farms that
include plants and animals working together to
regenerate soils, people, and communities.

Why A2A2 Milk is Better

In the not-too-distant past, all dairy cows exclusively produced A2 milk. After domestication and years of breeding, a DNA mutation occurred that led to A1 milk. But it's A2 milk that is produced by all mammals, humans included, making it a closer match to what is naturally intended for human consumption.

A2 milk has higher amounts of omega-3s and CLA’s, is easier to digest with fewer uncomfortable side effects, and contains heart healthy fats. Several studies have also shown that A2 proteins have superior metabolic and cognitive benefits.

The milk that makes our ice cream is from a small group of exceptional farms in New York, where the cows are known by name, and each one is lab tested and confirmed to produce only A2 proteins.

  • For Love & Lemon Cookies

    Rockville Center, LI

  • Janette

    Huntington Village, LI

  • Julie

    Locust Valley, LI

1 of 3

Find us at a Farmer’s
Market near you.

Our Markets


  • Oyster Bay
  • Locust Valley
  • Jericho
  • Syosset
  • Seaford
  • Rockville Center
  • Massapequa
  • Brookville
  • East Williston


  • Coming soon


  • Huntington
  • Babylon
  • Islip
  • West Hampton
  • Montauk
  • Lake Grove
  • Setauket
  • Sayville


  • Coming soon

Why Goodness Dairy?

We started out with a simple mission. To make ice cream we would feel good about feeding to our kids. This fundamental principle serves as the compass for all our choices. We have the most stringent quality standards and remain steadfast in our commitment to never compromise. With each scoop, we continue to passionately pursue our vision of offering wholesome mouthwatering indulgence to families everywhere.

Goodness Dairy Other Ice Cream
Local New York Dairy
Certified USDA Organic Dairy
Certified Regenerative Dairy
100% A2A2 Dairy
100% Grass-Fed Dairy
No Refined or Processed Sugar
No Fillers, Gums, or Preservatives
No Syrups or GMOs
No Canola or Vegetable Oils
Sweetened With Honey
Sweetened With Organic Maple Syrup
Organic Pasture Raised Eggs
  • Where does your milk come from?

    We source all of our milk from small family farms upstate New York. The farms are all certified organic and certified regenerative. The cows are A2A2 and are 100% grass-fed. The milk we use in our ice cream truly is exceptional.

  • Where is the ice cream made?

    Our ice cream is made from scratch upstate New York.

  • Is your ice cream pasteurized?

    Yes. All of our dairy products and eggs are pasteurized.

  • Does Goodness Dairy ship ice cream?

    Yes! We are currently shipping to customers in the Northeast.

  • How is the ice cream shipped?

    Our ice cream is packaged in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice to keep it frozen hard right to your doorstep.

  • Do I need to be home to accept my delivery?

    We ship with signature release so you do not have to be home to receive your order. But please make sure that you move your ice cream into the freezer as soon as possible!

  • Do you accept returns?

    No, unfortunately we are not able to accept returns. If you are experiencing an issue with your ice cream contact us and we’ll do our best to make it right.

  • I still have questions, who can I contact?

    We love helping our customers. Email us anytime at moo@goodnessdairy.com and you'll almost always get a reply within an hour or two.

1 of 8